Guest Stars Bobby Cannavale as Joe Alicia Coppola as Detective Patricia Damiana Skipp Sudduth as Jerry McCaffrey Leo Burmester as Father Peter Castoro Jack Gwaltney as Billy Bingham Ron McLarty as Father John Wendy Makkena as Agent Lamott Bellamy Young as Jane Sarah Hyland as Shy Girl Michael Potts as Detective Jackson Mark D. Espinoza as Raphael Marc John Jefferies as Kid #2 Robert Harte as Steven Scott Wentworth as Agent Quindlen Charles Reed as Errol Janet Metz as Nancy Melissa Remo as Kid #1 Jenise Bishop as Kid #3