Guest Stars Kyle Bornheimer as Jack Briggs Judy Greer as Judy Nadine Nicole as Casey Orion Austin Basis as Ethan Zane Rubin as Brenda Christopher Zash as Young Drew Co Starring Rachae Amber Thomas as Laura's Ride to Sacramento Tyler Osterkamp as Flatmate Talia Toms as Technician Erin Sossamon as Shelley Cate Cohen as Waffle Maker Salesclerk Michael Stellman as Guy at Hospital Mara Klein as Young Valerie Celesta DeAstis as Alex's Date MIchael Delgado as Dude on Bus