Guest Stars Mark Feuerstein as Mark Adam Scott as Ben Sarah Burns as Claire Alyssa Milano as Renata Samm Levine as Arty Jai Courtney as Garth MacArthur Beth Dover as Shari Melanie Lynskey as Laura Rob Huebel as Brodfard Gilroy Co Starring Craig Rowin as Brad Roxana Ortega as Kim's Customer T.J. Alvarado as Angie Shea Lewis as Flair Bartender Double