Special Guest Stars Lucy Lawless as Countess Marburg Guest Stars Jeremy Crutchley as Hathorne Sammi Hanratty as Dollie Trask Christopher Berry as Petrus Thomas Francis Murphy as Reverend Lewis Stuart Townsend as Dr. Samuel Wainwright Raoul Trujillo as The Shaman Cara Santana as Sooleawa Henri Lubatti as Thomas Eliot Co Starring Juli Erickson as Ancient Witch #2 Clint James as Blacksmith Jennifer Griffin as Ancient Witch #1 Toby Nichols as Kid Katie Gunderson as Annie the Whore Camden Flowers as Girl Luke Sexton as Militiaman Mallory Thompson as Plague Victim