Guest Stars Mark Feuerstein as Mark Adam Scott as Ben Sarah Burns as Claire Alyssa Milano as Renata Samm Levine as Arty Jai Courtney as Garth MacArthur Anne-Marie Johnson as Burkhart Skyler Gisondo as Deegs Joey Bragg as Seth David Wain as Clinton Co Starring Nikki SooHoo as Female White House Staffer Jessie Franks as Softball Camper Soledad St. Hilaire as Sunny Day Rep Kevin Mangold as Arrow Hit Camper Malik Aziz as Public Access Host Matt Baker as ATC Driver Krister Johnson as Male White House Staffer Thomas Robie as Softball Pitcher