Guest Stars Michael Mulheren as George Sibley Sammi Hanratty as Dollie Trask Stephen Lang as Increase Mather Co Starring Morgana Shaw as Mab Thomas Francis Murphy as Reverend Lewis Mary Katherine O'Donnell as Emily Lucy Faust as Elizabeth Juli Erickson as Ancient Witch #2 Heaven Needham as Acolyte #1 Jennifer Griffin as Ancient Witch #1 Amber Dawn Landrum as Acolyte #2 Benjamin Mouton as Lamb Dane Rhodes as Henry Hopkins Braden Fitzgerald as Stephen