Guest Stars Nathan Baesel as Deputy Lewis Sirk Jake Richardson as Gage McKittrick Veronica Cartwright as Valerie Shenkman Ivar Brogger as Father Jeffrey Scanlon Michael Mitchell as Derek Culie Matt Ross as Vince Teracona Stephen Lee as Carl McKittrick Sylva Kelegian as Lucy McKittrick Co Starring Reggie Jordan as Reporter Robert Dickenson as Newscaster Matt Sigloch as M.P. Jake Eberle as Man Saida Rodriguez Pagan as Newscaster #2