Guest Stars John Leary as Dave Brendan Cowell as Harry Wayne Blair as Father Whyman Lani John Tupu as Jimmy Chris Haywood as Gene Valerie Bader as Carol Robin Goldsworthy as Stephen Roz Hammond as Christine Frances O'Donnell as Young Audrey Shane Addison as Waiter River Olson as Altar Boy Sally Seltmann as Church Musician Matt Blackman as Church Musician