Guest Stars Alan Hale Jr. as Bartender at Broken Saddle Don Stroud as Arnold Stuart Whitman as Buck Yancy/Rough Rider Pat Buttram as Jonathan Evans/Toby Bridget Hanley as Shelby Barnett John Russell as Second Oldtimer at Broken Saddle Broderick Crawford as Kern Barnett Alice Nunn as Barney Jock Mahoney as First Oldtimer at Broken Saddle