Guest Stars Cedric Sanders as Young Kronish Keedar Whittle as Reverend Leslie Gwen Hollander as Young Diane James Austin Johnson as Young Gabe Emily Goss as Vanessa Charlie McDermott as Young Barry Co Starring Hana Hayes as Debbie Jamal Duff as Burly Security Guard Michele Panu as Tiffany James Frey as Security Guard Carly Shukiar as Amber Rebecca King as Sheryl