Guest Stars Roger Bart as Angelo David Hoffman as Jim Nate Smith as Mike Andrew Schulz as Mitch Daniel B. Strauss as Alan Georgina Reilly as Sarah Kate Vernon as Mrs. De Cordova Josh Zuckerman as Justin Matt McCoy as Father Mike David Paymer as Dr. Neuberger Co Starring Alison Martin as Lorraine Klavin Jill Basey as Congregant #1 Dominic Oliver as Congregant #2 Jason Denuszek as Congregant #3 Uncredited Brett Rice as Andy's Dad