Guest Stars Peter Gwinn as Andy Judy Greer as Gretchen Danielle MacDonald as Grace Co Starring Jacqueline Toboni as Jo Dre Marquis as Grace's Friend #4 Tim Kazurinsky as Father Timothy Joette Waters as Homeless Person #3 David Woolley as Homeless Person #2 Kebin L. Carr as Homeless Person #1 Michael Saguto as Bible Study Teen #1 Sophie Traub as Stephanie Lillie Cummings as Grace's Friend #2 Khloe Janel as Grace's Friend #1 Alex Ross Perry as Mr. Pope Brooke Breit as Bank Worker Miriam Moss as Grace's Friend #3 Marissa Banker as Bible Study Teen #2 Jordan Brodess as Jake