Guest Stars Lachlan Watson as Susie Putnam / Theo Gavin Leatherwood as Nicholas Scratch Abigail F. Cowen as Dorcas Christopher Rosamond as Mr. Kinkle Darren Mann as Luke Chalfant Adrian Hough as Joe Putnam Bronson Pinchot as George Hawthorne Brenda McDonald as Dezmelda Justin Dobies as Tommy Kinkle Alvina August as Lady Constance Blackwood L. Scott Caldwell as Nana Ruth Walker Sarah Jane Redmond as Mrs. Kemper Michael Hogan as Grampa Kinkle Co Starring Ty Wood as Billy Marlin Peter Bundic as Carl Tapper Anastasia Bandey as Dorothea Putnam Carmel Amit as Mildred Cynthia Mendez as Female Coven Choir #3 Arielle Tuliao as Female Coven Choir #1 Moses Thiessen as Ben Button Kimi Alexander as Female Coven Choir #2 Anita Wittenberg as Witch #1 Maria Epih as Witch #2 Eunice Kang as Female Coven Choir #4