Guest Stars Lachlan Watson as Susie Putnam / Theo Gavin Leatherwood as Nicholas Scratch Abigail F. Cowen as Dorcas Christopher Rosamond as Mr. Kinkle Darren Mann as Luke Chalfant Adrian Hough as Joe Putnam Justin Dobies as Tommy Kinkle Co Starring Ty Wood as Billy Marlin Peter Bundic as Carl Tapper Annette Reilly as Diana Spellman Anastasia Bandey as Dorothea Putnam Panthea Vatandoost as Screaming Student Charmaine Wilson as Crone