Guest Stars Andrew Rannells voices Matthew MacDell Richard Kind voices Marty Glouberman Joe Wengert voices Caleb Seth Morris voices Greg Glaser Gina Rodriguez voices Gina Alvarez David Thewlis voices Lionel St. Swithens John Gemberling voices Tyler Pico Joe Wengert voices Rabbi Paulblart Harvey Fierstein voices Jerome Jerry Minor voices Man #3 Jerry Minor voices Singing Fish John Gemberling voices Dot #1 Joe Wengert voices Dot #3 Gil Ozeri voices Dot #2 Gil Ozeri voices Man #1 Mark Rivers voices Man #2 Mark Rivers voices Penis Worms Ashley London voices Skank