Guest Stars Carlo Rota as Anton LaVey Billy Eichner as Mutt Nutter Harriet Sansom Harris as Madelyn Dominic Burgess as Phil Sandra Bernhard as Hannah Co Starring Kingston Foster as Angelic Girl Roger Hewlett as Doorman Tice Proctor as Angelic Boy Alhan Bilal as Office Girl J.T. Sherwood as Theodore Megan Davis as Call Girl Jim Deangelo as Elder #2 Garrett Westton as Male Angel Rachael Drummond as Worshipper #1 Cole Stratton as Worshipper #2 Lauren Mungo as Leticia Gloria Laino as Elder #1