Guest Stars Sarah Gadon as Elisa Montgomery Brett Cullen as Gerald Kindt Mamie Gummer as Lucy Purcell Isaiah C. Morgan as Young Henry Hays Michael Greyeyes as Brett Woodard Jon Tenney as Alan Jones Rhys Wakefield as Freddy Burns Kennedi Lynn Butler as Young Becca Hays Emily Nelson as Margaret Josh Hopkins as Jim Dobkins Tim Griffin as Special Agent Burt Diller Michael Broderick as Special Agent John Bowen Brian Oerly as Eddie Brandon Flynn as Ryan Peters Richard Meehan as Frankie Boyle Gareth Williams as Police Chief Warren Michael Graziadei as Dan O'Brien Jaiden Alexander McLeod as Wayne's Grandson Michael Klucher as Reporter Bailey Rae Fenderson as Amy Hays Corbin B. Pitts as Mike Ardoin Sola Bamis as Heather Hays Lawrence Turner as Foreman Keith Hudson as Ernest Michael Papajohn as Rich Josh Whites as Joe Jennifer Pierce Mathus as Daycare Matron Shawn-Caulin Young as Ted LaGrange Cody Shelton as Don Sara Edgerton as Worried Woman Thomas W. Moore as Worried Man Alyson Courtney as TBD Natalie Canerday as Eloise Purcell David Jensen as Roy Purcell