Guest Stars Ryan Michelle Bathe as Detective Jennifer Paige Danny Nucci as Detective Sanford Motta Joelle Carter as Mrs. Mitchell Spence Moore II as Campbell, Jr. Shawn Christian as Jeremy Hawke Aaron D. Spears as Campbell, Sr. Michael Chieffo as Homicide Witness Co Starring Christopher Murray as Old Cop Mike Ostroski as Camper Dad Shalin Agarwal as Bartender Tyler Sanders as Logan Hawke Michael Fitzgerald as Everett York Alex Denney as Leshawn Halvorsen Tyler Beveridge as Security Guard