Guest Stars Jimmi Simpson as Peter Rake Sutton Foster as Laura Julianna Guill as Kara Wheeler Stephanie Beatriz as Elena Mary McCormack as Lilith Michael Weston as Lonnie Shaunette Renée Wilson as Marie Kylie Rogers as Riley Rake Nancy Linehan Charles as Agnes Amanda Walsh as Gwen Rake Sophia del Pizzo as Morgan Co Starring Cass Buggé as Delivery Girl Cyrina Fiallo as Katie Brittini London as Production Assistant Uncredited Maggie Lawson as Rebecca Wheeler