Guest Stars Royce Johnson as Detective Sergeant Brett Mahoney Deborah Ann Woll as Karen Page Annette O'Toole as Eliza Schultz Joseph D. Reitman as Creepy Ed Derek Roberts as Officer Lawrence Kareem Savinon as Officer Smith Gene Gillette as Officer O'Rourke Kate Rigg as Dr. Mason Reagan Grella as Young Krista Lissa Danshaw as Paramedic