Guest Stars Joel de la Fuente as Dr. Johann Pryce Kaniehtiio Horn as Destiny Rumancek Nicole Boivin as Young Shelley Amazon Eve as Young Shelley Laurie Fortier as Marie Godfrey Kandyse McClure as Dr. Clementine Chasseur Ted Dykstra as Francis Pullman Aaron Douglas as Tom Sworn Lili Taylor as Lynda Rumancek Marty Adams as Neck Eliana Jones as Alexa Sworn Emilia McCarthy as Alyssa Sworn Philip Craig as Bishop Holly Deveaux as Jenny Fredericks Don Francks as Nicolae Rumancek Emily Piggford as Ashley Valentine Dylan Trowbridge as Nose Alanis Peart as Mrs. Pisarro Jacqueline Graham as Lisa Willoughby Landon Norris as Tyler Joe Bostick as Vice Principal Steve Lund as Bartender Krista Marchand as Sleepy Woman Alexander Marsh as Young Roman Carolyne Maraghi as Caroline