Guest Stars Tom Bosley as Sheriff Amos Tupper Claude Akins as Captain Ethan Cragg Patti D'Arbanville as Leslie Andler Edward Albert as Tony Holiday Stuart Whitman as Charles Woodley June Allyson as Katie Simmons Van Johnson as Daniel O'Brien Co Starring Paddi Edwards as Lois Hoey David Ashrow as Umpire Bruce Gray as Dean Merrill Lois Foraker as Eliza Bates Ed Morgan as Local #2 Harry Stephens as Doctor G.R. Smith as Deputy Dee Croxton as Cora McIntyre Doug Stevenson as Gas Attendant Roger Price as Local #1 Uncredited Steven Ameche as Musician