Guest Stars Scott Porter as Pastor Seth McPherson Annalisa Cochrane as KellyAnn McKaley Miller as Jo Ciara Bravo as Lacey Jahkara J. Smith as Shay Jonathan Chase as Steve Jim Klock as Kyle Co Starring T.C. Carter as Gabe Jose Valazquez as Jack Tara Parker as Lilith Monroe Cline as Choreographer Madeleine Gardella as Ballerina 1 Ashley Dawn Smith as Ballerina 2 Kiira Norris-Turin as Ballerina 3 Kanie Sequoia as Ballerina 4