Guest Stars Sam Puefua as Herman Pola Pollyanna McIntosh as Clara Vik Sahay as Tarquin Olivia Sandoval as Janet Price Mary Elizabeth Ellis as Daphne Larson Paul Giamatti as L. Marvin Metz Chum Ehelepola as Anil Susy Kane as Genevieve Paul F. Tompkins as Farrell Higgins Co Starring Alex Klein as Leo Kai Daniels as Young Sean Dudley Emily Rose Platt as Young Liz Dudley James Logan as Man with Eyepatch Greg Allan Martin as Elegant Man Jeff Cole as FBI Agent #1 Julio Cesar Ruiz as Mariachi #1