Guest Stars Alicia Coppola as Sheila Mosconi Leo Howard as Tommy Harte Katie Finneran as Naomi Harte Lindsey Kraft as Claire Peta Murgatroyd as Tango Dancer Maksim Chmerkovskiy as Tango Dancer Odelya Halevi as Willow Kevin William Paul as Mischa Co Starring Marcel Nahapetian as Benny Maria Russell as Sandy Jay Brian Winnick as Barclay Jean St. James as Mimi Carlos Barrionuevo as Stranger Alex Rene as Waiter David Banks as Bartender