Guest Stars Aaron Douglas as Evan Henderson Jewel Staite as Caroline Swift Ben Cotton as Pastor Mike Sheehan Nicholas Lea as Dale Daniel Shannon Ryan Robbins as Joe Mills James Lewis as Alton Hill Grace Zabriskie as Margery "Mama" Dips Co Starring Katherine Evans as Bethany Skinner Ingrid Torrance as Tess Clarke Jenn MacLean-Angus as Jennifer Skinner Jeff Gladstone as Man Jake Croker as Kid Laine MacNeil as Teenage Girl Nelson Leis as Stony Mystic Billy Wickman as Dude #1 Gavin Cooke as Tubby Guard Harrison MacDonald as Teenage Boy Leanne Merrett as Dale's Intended Hannah Jeffery as Tina Uncredited Zack Lavoie as Tank