Guest Stars Jazzy Kae as Anna Baker Amy Hohn as Judge Sally Volk Alok Tewari as ADA Williams Malcolm Goodwin as Eddie Mitchell Christina Shea-Wright as Detective Valerie Cobb Nile Bullock as Young Eddie Mitchell Karmine Alers as Maria Garcia Juan Carlos Díaz as Isaac Garcia Co Starring Theis Weckesser as Uniformed Officer Susan Oliveras as Staffer Aaron Morton as Louis Grant Quincy Giles as Marcus Lott Sadat Waddy as Young Louis Grant Uncredited Matt Servitto voices Doctor