Special Guest Stars Mike O'Malley as Tim Eavers Guest Stars Tom Irwin as Fred Micklen Janina Gavankar as Alison Namazi Co Starring Victoria Tate as Rena Robinson Joe Marinelli as Donny Eli Bildner as Joel Rapkin Amber Friendly as Layla Bell Andrea Bendewald as Valerie Kay Augustus Prew as Sean Hiddleberg Katherine Ko as Dhillon Ian Gomez as Greg Kate Vernon as Geneva Roman Mitichyan as Sam Briana Nicole Henry as Alyssa Paul Witten as Austin Alain Uy as Jimmy Buckley Sampson as Kate Ivan Fuchs as Man in Pilot Candice Marie Bennett as Woman in Pilot Chris Dougherty as Eric Matthew Butcher as Hired Firefighter Al Coronel as Mike Carrie Armstrong as Woman Alice Lin as Jimmy's Grandmother Andre Johnson as Stage Manager