Guest Stars Curtis Lum as Calvin David Cubitt as Ted Pownall Hannah Levien as Janine Georgia Waters as Eliza Millan Tesfazgi as Cami Sedale Threatt Jr. as Levi Aylya Marzolf as Katrina Katie Keough as Hunter (Mermaid) Deniz Akdeniz as Robb Wellens Jill Teed as Widow McClure Ary Katz as Mate Co Starring Tammy Gillis as Deputy Marissa Staub Megan Danso as Annie Brennan Amy Goodmurphy as Kate Madeleine Kelders as Training Officer Kapila Rego as Mom #4 Nicole Anthony as Instructor Gili Roskies as Mom #3 Jodi Pongratz as Waitress Celia Aloma as Mom #1 Vonnie Bennetto as Customer Niamh Taylor as Mom #2