Guest Stars Rebecca Schull as Emma Jessica Meraz as Natalie Ortiz Parker Mack as Finn Madill Aurora Perrineau as Margo Greg Germann as William Conti Timothy Granaderos as Gabe Kaylee Bryant as Sydney Brian McGovern as Timothy Carson John Billingsley as Edwin Shaw Leisha Hailey as Juliet Christine Lekas as Rose Carson Vaz Andreas as Wedding Emcee Reamy Hall as Nancy Carson Pat McNeely as Grandma Ida