Guest Stars Autry Haydon-Wilson as Janus Forsythe Silas Weir Mitchell as Boyd Suttree Denis Shepherd as Teenage Yates Forsythe John Marshall Jones as Ronny Pearson Matt Battaglia as Younger Judge Forsythe Jason Davis as Claude Shifflet Austin Freeman as Teenage Boyd Suttree Charmin Lee as Poochie LaVerne Maximiliano Hernández as Wallace Cox Joe Chrest as Jasper Cruikshank Co Starring Michael Kendall Kaplan as Davis Forsythe Jackson Tessmer as Reynolds Forsythe Paul Danner as Teenage Dickie Barrett Cory Scott Allen as Bobby Caso David Tatman as Minister Lauren L. Murray as Younger Byrd Forsythe Anthony Marshall as Young Ronny Pearson Kevin Patrick Murphy as Shopkeeper Escalante Lundy as Hank Kamille McCuin as Beverly Pearson Jeremy Sande as Guard Alyssa Wininger as Teenage Marci Strong