Guest Stars Amy Ryan voices Michelle McNamara Patton Oswalt as Himself Paul Haynes as Himself Lauren Orlando as Michelle McNamara Melanie Barbeau as Herself Paul Holes as Himself Gay Hardwick as Herself Bob Hardwick as Himself Jennifer Barth as Herself Daniel Greenberg as Himself Drew Witthuhn as Himself Kera Bolonik as Herself Mary Rita Skrine as Herself