Special Guest Stars Corey Stoll as Charles Wainwright Guest Stars Amanda Plummer as Louise Alice Englert as Dolly Vincent D'Onofrio as Governor George Wilburn Liz Femi as Patient Leona Robert Curtis Brown as Monsignor Sullivan Hunter Parrish as Father Andrews Daniel Di Tomasso as Dario Salvatore David Wells as Father Murphy Emily Mest as Nurse Amelia Emerson Co Starring Jermaine Williams as Harold Carie Kawa as Secretary Greg Winter as Father Dennis McMurtry Siaka Massaquoi as Father Adeyemi Aaron Jay Rome as Photographer #2 Brian Maillard as Father Coleman Wes Armstrong as Daniel Clayton Farris as Reporter #1 Robert Henry as Photographer #1 Jake McDermott as Attendant Kirk Bovill as Prison Representative Jim Bentley as Maître d Breck Denny as Burly Orderly Patrick Conboy as Burly Man Damien Luvara as Bartender Sammie Wayne as Reporter #2 Kaseen E. Buchholz as Blonde Woman