Guest Stars John Cho as Andy Brooks Clancy Brown as Sheriff August Corbin Nestor Serrano as Polygrapher Co Starring Patrick Gorman as Reverend Knapp Jahnee Wallace as Young Abbie Michael Tourek as Prison Guard Dwayne Boyd as Sleepy Hollow Officer #2 Chris Walters as Sleepy Hollow Officer #1 Elaine Nalee as Doctor Aerli Austen as Waitress Huntington Daly as Aide Nat Padget as Militiaman