Special Guest Stars Blythe Danner as Demeter Guest Stars Julia Sweeney as Ann-Marie Hinzelmann Eric Johnson as Chad Mulligan Lela Loren as Marguerite Olsen Denis O'Hare as Tyr Bea Santos as Trending Mercedes Morris as Meme Nabeel El Khafif as Hank Danny Trejo as Mr. World Tom York as Colonial Wednesday Aaron Poole as Colonial Tyr Co Starring Spencer MacPherson as Derek David Reale as Dr. Fapp Jane Spidell as Mabel Gabriel Mattka as Leon Olsen Gwynne Phillips as Colonial Demeter Jill Harland as Susan McGovern Cameron Alexander Green as Jack McGovern Adrian Griffin as Townsperson #2 Marcia Bennett as Older Woman Birgitte Solem as Townsperson #1 Eric Woolfe as Puppeteer #2 Emily Shelton as Elizabeth Thomas Rickert as Piano Player Doug MacLeod as Older Man Zenna Davis-Jones as Elsa Kato Alexander as Sexy Single Man Timothy L. Hill as Puppeteer #1