Guest Stars Graham Rogers as Jude Jenna Lyng Adams as Darshani Melissa Tang as Margaret Chen Casey Thomas Brown as Lane Emily Osment as Theresa Ashleigh LaThrop as Breana Lisa Edelstein as Phoebe Newlander Haley Joel Osment as Robbie Schumacher J.D. Walsh as Judd Melman Marianne Muellerleile as Waitress Co Starring Lyn Alicia Henderson as Young Woman