Guest Stars Elvis Nolasco as Nat Pettigrew Kathrine Narducci as Olympia Gigante Dominic Fumusa as Father Louis Gigante Chazz Palminteri as Giuseppe "Joe" Bonanno Paul Sorvino as Frank Costello Grace Porter as Betty Shabazz Maurice Jones as Captain Omar Isaach De Bankolé as Monsieur 98 Peter Francis James as Archie Gaines Justin Bartha as Robert Morgenthau Leopold Manswell as Captain Henry Co Starring Afi Bijou as Sister Marny Bo Dietl as Thomas Lucchese Anthony Aquilino as Carlo Gambino Louis Vanaria as Lombardi Evander Duck, Jr. as Brother Clinkscale Michael Early as Brother Dayton True Whitaker as Sandra Stephen Christopher Marshall as Federal Marshal Rocco Parente as Profaci Boss Edward Manley as Federal Agent Tom Scorzone as Driver