Guest Stars Allisyn Ashley Arm as Heather Willmore Aparna Brielle as Sarika Sarkar Jacob Houston as Victor Kozlowski Eddie Leavy as Anthony Lewis Nick Peine as Marcus Kasperak Sari Arambulo as Grace Spence Moore II as Dan Decker Marisa Baram as Marissa Hayley Marie Norman as Shayla Howard Joe Manganiello as Malachi Janine Brito as Kylie Co Starring Jacob Timothy Manown as Caleb Baker Miguel Chavez as Eduardo Yuyao Deng as Yuyao Deng David Douglas as Paul (Waiter)