Guest Stars Abraham Rodriguez as Spencer Buckley DeShawn Cavanaugh as Colt Cassidy Mariah I. Wilson as Nadia Coleman Matthew Sato as Gil Vatooley Ariela Barer as Chloe Co Starring Christian Weissman as Nate Kellen Joseph as The Fish Ashley London as Popular Girl Max Banta as Strong Silent Type Elaine Whae as Jock Girl Sabrina Schloss as Type-A Nerd Armani Barrett as Handsome Dunny Chris Schleicher as Spirit Proctor Kathy Wigfield as Librarian Holger Moncada, Jr. as State Farm Agent Uncredited Tiffani Thiessen as Kelly Kapowski Morris Mark-Paul Gosselaar as Governor Zack Morris