Guest Stars Kylie Liya Page as Cassie Wilkins Ella Rubin as Natalie Gibson Kristin Griffith as Janice Roy Chinasa Ogbuagu as Teresa Adams Aya Cash as Katie Rayburn Scott William Winters as Eric Dawicki Kelly AuCoin as Detective Gordon Jeff Wahlberg as Rob Mahoney Pearl Amanda Dickson as Susie Pierce Co Starring Callie McClincy as Hayden Carter Leah Thompkins as Paige Roy Ella Kennedy Davis as Sydney Roy Carrie Walrond Hood as Julia Pierce John Henry Ward as Adrian Peters Rachael Thompson as Val Craig Anton as Samuel Sutter Dallas Oshae as O'Connor Alexandra Boylan as Waitress Zechariah Pierce as Priest Taylor Castro as Carla Josiah Bracken as Jimmy Vanna Pilgrim as Paralegal 1 Lucas Scott Budde as Crewman 1 Kassidy Cook as Crewman 2 Scott Pattison as Crewman 3 Markis Gallashaw as Crewman 4 Kevin Marshall as Crewman 5