Guest Stars Ramona Edith Williams as Makayla Burgess Robbie Collier Sublett as Daniel Smith Co Starring Alejandro Raya as Patrol Officer Caswith Matthew Lucki as Tommy Grace Jason Bradley as Detective Sharyon Culberson as Patrol Officer Jennings Mary Beth Burns as Clerk John B. McCann as Jim Wheaton James Konicek as Forensic Tech Stacie Doublin as Psychologist John Grant-Phillips as Dr. Magnuson Ally Tully as Jada Grace Emmett Genter as Young Daniel Drew Genter as Mark Smith Danielle Genter as Isabella Smith