Guest Stars Ashley Taylor Greaves as Officer Gabrielle Taylor Cyndee Rivera as Detective Mia Ruz Aidan Quinn as Burton Lowe Lou Liberatore as Andrew Kristen Connolly as Audrey O'Neill Kelly AuCoin as Father John Regis Patch Darragh as Father Ryan Duffy Daniel Passaro as Vince Costa Malachy Cleary as Attorney Gordon Matthews Roberts Jekabsons as Shane O'Neill Cara Cooper as Caitlin McKenna Traci Wolfe as Beverly Morrison Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration