Guest Stars Addison Timlin as Delilah Seth Gabel as Pastor Walter Julia Schlaepfer as Celeste Cody Fern as Thomas Browne Ian Sharkey as Edward Browne Co Starring Steven J. Oliver as Old Man Mark Daneri as Doctor Cameron Lee Price as Daniel Lauren Baldwin as Congregant 2 Andrew Garrett as Congregant 3 Peter Banachowski as Congregant Sanya Arnold as Rachel Tyler Adkins as Abram Madonna Young-Magee as Elderly Woman Kelton White as Young Man