Guest Stars Efrem Zimbalist, Jr. as Dandy Jim Buckley Leo Gordon as Big Mike McComb Richard Long as Gentleman Jack Darby Diane Brewster as Samantha Crawford Arlene Howell as Cindy Lou Brown Jonathan Hole as Brent Williams Karl Swenson as Sheriff Griffin John Dehner as John Bates Joan Young as Susan Granville Syd Saylor as Townsman Irving Bacon as Employee Regis Toomey as Ben Granville Val Benedict as Cowhand Earle Hodgins as Ernest Plunkett Uncredited J. Pat O'Malley as Ambrose Callahan Luis Delgado as Townsman Ralph Reed as Bellboy Jim Bert Stevens as Diner Patron Leon Tyler as Henry Hibbs Cactus Mack as Stage Driver Herb