Guest Stars Leslie Uggams as Isabel Zucker Judd Hirsch as David Goldblatt Nick Kroll voices Alpha Marianne Rendón as Gabriela Judy Gold as Sophie Annelise Cepero as Julia Neska Rose as Alana Goldblatt Kathryn Kates as Mrs. Goldblatt Co Starring Martin Fisher as Jeremy (FBI) Adam B. Shapiro as Richard Klubeck Kapil Bawa as Dr. Shah Zell Steele Morrow as Max Borenstein Allen McCullough as Rev. McGhee Quinn Jackson as Myra (FBI) Lynn Kim Do as Nurse Shirleyann Kaladjian as Dahlia Klubeck Fredi Bernstein as Devoted Congregant David Kramer as Lawrence Zabler Laura Patinkin as Sarah Stillman Rosanna Magarelli as Sharon Sean Shannon as Homeless Elijah