Guest Stars Liam Pileggi as Ian Montgomery Amelie Dallimore as Jenny Montgomery Kira Pozehl as Elaine Williams Matthew Posey as Bob Pomeroy Harper Heath as Alisa Gore Bruce McGill as Judge Tom Ryan Beth Broderick as Bertha Pomeroy Mackenzie Astin as Tom O'Connell Adam Cropper as Robert Udashen Brad Leland as Chief Royce Abbott Christin Sawyer Davis as Elaine Carpenter Brian d'Arcy James as Dr. Fred Fason Dave Maldonado as Detective Jim Cochran Chris Freihofer as Agent Joe Murphy Co Starring Garrett Graham as Officer Steve Deffibaugh Jophielle Love as Young Candy Patrick A. Grover as Reporter Jones Jackie Ritz as Young Celeste Gigi Erneta as News Anchor Eric Cepeda as Reporter Jenkins Allison Poccia as Reporter Kia J. Williams as Reporter Alexis Kim Barnes as Reporter Smith Adriana Scamardi as Flight Attendant Molly Mulhern as Detention Officer Ken Orman as Technician McElroy Lucas McCutchen as Douglas Swanson Tiana Stuart as Soloist Joe Daru as Dr. Holden