Guest Stars Amelie Dallimore as Jenny Montgomery Liam Pileggi as Ian Montgomery Olivia Applegate as Carol Crowder Sara Burke as Barbara Green Kira Pozehl as Elaine Williams Bonnie Gayle Sparks as Jo Ann Garlington Matthew Posey as Bob Pomeroy Aaron Jay Rome as Richard Garlington Jennifer Neala Page as Betty Huffhines Bruce McGill as Judge Tom Ryan Mackenzie Astin as Tom O'Connell Adam Cropper as Robert Udashen Christin Sawyer Davis as Elaine Carpenter Brian d'Arcy James as Dr. Fred Fason Co Starring Jophielle Love as Young Candy Sunday Dangerstone as Tina Grant Jackie Ritz as Young Celeste Natalia Borja as Judy Swaine Tyler Matthew Harris as Foreman Snyder Daemon Pedroza as Bailiff Kat Steffens as Catherine Cooper Jonathan Flanders as Officer Stimson Kenneisha Thompson as Reporter Jane Patrick Gathron as Reporter Bob