Guest Stars Seamus Dever as Andy the German Shea Whigham as Mitch Decker Steven Williams as Alan Sanborn Eric T. Esparza as Joe Turner Matthew Menalo as Rocket Rosen Mark Speno as Doug Tinker Kieran Mulcare as Terry Nichols Paul Dillon as Pappy Millar Co Starring Nicholas Kolev as Paul Fatta Mimi Fletcher as Jury Forewoman Lori Rae Marie Wagenman as Child Karen Doyle Jacob Browne as Arkansas Prison Guard Chip Carriere as Richard Snell Chris Bylsma as Federal Jail Guard Asha Bee as Polo Lounge Hostess Owen Conway as Derelict Tony Robinette as Eldon Elliott Edgar Damatian as Polo Lounge Bartender Credit Only Gary Cole as Gordon Novel J. Smith-Cameron as Lois Roden John Leguizamo as Jacob Vasquez