Guest Stars Lauren Buglioli as Kaitlin Fox Clark Gregg as Deputy Ketcher Mark Jeffrey Miller as Buzz Leonard Earl Howze as Ray-Ray Isabel Gameros as Tyler Sibongile Mlambo as Clara Michael Esper as Deacon Paul Schneider as Officer Andy Boone Paul Brian Johnson as Dunney Co Starring Kellen Boyle as Randy Candy McLellan as Officer Lacey Amber Erwin as Caroline Madison Brandon Germaine as Ted Madison Kelsi Chandler as Gas Station Woman Zachary Dylan Brown as Restaurant Patron