Guest Stars D'Arcy Carden as Natalie Greer Zachary Golinger as John Berkman Jr. Annie Chang as Josie Spenser Granese as Bevel Adrian Sparks as Diner Owner Emily Spivey as Ginny Co Starring Brian Konowal as Father Sander Thomas as Travis Steve Bannos as Old Cook Matthew Floyd Miller as Minister Heath McGough as Kyle Franky Guttman as Security Officer Sabrina Saleha as TBD